 Original article
 Open access
 Published:
Designing a solar and wind hybrid system for smallscale irrigation: a case study for Kalangala district in Uganda
Energy, Sustainability and Society volume 10, Article number: 6 (2020)
Abstract
Background
Dynamics in rainfall patterns are posing a threat to crop production in Uganda. Irrigation can be used to ensure constant production; however, the motorized powered irrigation methods are quite costly to run in addition to being environmentally unsustainable. There is thus need for alternative irrigation methods. Renewable energy sources which are readily available can be used to power irrigation systems. This study hence sought to design an appropriate windsolar hybrid system for irrigating 1 acre of banana plantation in Kalangala district, Uganda.
Methods
Using metrological data, mean wind speed and monthly solar irradiance of global radiation horizontal for the district were analysed. A windsolar hybrid system was optimally designed for a standalone drip irrigation system of 450 banana plants on 1acre land with water requirement of 33.73 m^{3} d^{−1}. The wind turbine was simulated to analyse for static pressure, cut plane flow behaviour, turbulence intensity and stress distribution exposed at 20 m s^{−1} wind speed. A cost analysis was done to estimate the total project investment, maintenance and operational cost, annual project gross income, net income stream and the annual net real rate of returns.
Results and conclusions
The simulation results showed that the system could effectively operate at speeds of 20 m s^{−1} without deformation. The net present value of income stream for the first 5 years at r = 5% was 12,935,468 UGX with a net real rate of return of 3.5% per year. The study will, therefore, be a useful guideline in making investment decisions in hybrids irrigation systems.
Background
Over 78% of Uganda’s population engage in agriculture [1] hence making it a backbone of the country’s economy. However, climate change/variability has continued to affect crop and livestock production making these economic ventures unreliable. Irrigation has the potential to solve problems of water and food security arising from climate change impacts [2]. However, irrigation requires both energy and water to operate. Water and energy are two interdependent sectors with a predicted 40% increase in energy demand leading to a 30% increase in water demand [3]. These high energy demands hence make irrigation adoption limited economically especially to the majority of smallholder farmers who earn less than a dollar per day. To combat this challenge of overreliance on the conventional grid and motorized pumps for irrigation, renewable energy irrigation pumps are gaining importance [4]. There is a growing trend to explore alternative renewable energy sources in Uganda, apart from hydropower, to boost the growing industrial sector. Solar and wind water pumping is a promising alternative to Uganda’s convection diesel or petrol and electricity water pumping systems [5]. This is because the country has an equatorial climate characterized with abundant sunshine and moderate wind speeds. Further industrial development will be attributed to reliable and highquality energy sources and this will constitute a substantial increase in quality of life for Ugandan citizens [6].
Developing and adopting environmentally sound renewable energy technologies will aid in modernizing agriculture and improving the livelihoods of vast Ugandans [5]. However, due to the dynamics of renewable resources, use of any particular renewable energy resource system as a standalone may lead to in operation during some time of the day and seasons and unnecessary operational and lifecycle costs, as well as components oversizing. These limitations can be overcome by combining two or more renewable energy resources in the form of a hybrid system [7], such as a photovoltaic system and a wind turbine [2]. A hybrid system has the advantage of improved reliability and gives better energy service when compared to a standalone supply system [2, 7]. Designing renewable energy hybrid systems involves sizing and selecting the best components to provide affordable, efficient and effective renewable energy [2].
Hybrid systems utilizing wind and solar energy have been designed for irrigation systems [2, 4], rural electrification [7] and wastewater treatment [8], and they have proved to be costeffective and efficient. The population of Kalangala district was estimated at 54,293 people in 2014 growing at 3% per year [9]. The biggest part of Kalangala district is unelectrified due to its isolated location on an island and low economy, but presents it with an opportunity to use renewable energy technologies. Extension of utility grid lines to most remote and nonelectrified areas experiences problems like; high capital investment, high lead time, low load factor, poor voltage regulation, and frequent power supply interruptions [10]. Therefore, a hybrid power system that is costeffective, none polluting and reliable was proposed to mitigate the scarcity of electricity for crop irrigation in Kalangala district. However, there is scanty scientific information on the utilization of solarwind hybrid systems to meet irrigation energy requirement in Uganda. Thus, the main objective of this study was to access the potential and viability of a windsolar hybrid drip irrigation system using Kalangala district as a case study.
Methods
Kalangala district headquarters are located at a latitude − 0.32 and 32.29 longitude [11]. The district has a perimeter of 387 km with a total area of 9066.8 km^{2} of which water covers 95%. Majority of the population is involved in clustered fishing along the shores of Lake Victoria. The district can only be accessed by ferries which were provided by the Ugandan government and local boats, as there are no bridges linking the islands to the mainland. Fishing, tourism and palm oil production by BIDCO oil refinery (U) Limited are the main revenue generators of the district. Although the district has got good climate conditions, some crops are greatly affected during the prolonged drought from the month of January to March, thus the need for irrigation to maintain a constant flow of water to crops throughout the year.
Data analysis
Okou [11] analysed Kalangala district solar and wind data of 4 years obtained from the metrological station of National Agricultural crop Resource Research Institute (NACRRI). In his analysis, he obtained the highest average wind speed over the 4 years which was 2.2 m s^{−2} at 10 m. The months of February to April and June to July registered the highest wind speeds ranging from 3.22 m s^{−2} to 8 m s^{−2}. December to January registered the lowest wind speeds of 0.4 m s^{−2} to 0.9 m s^{−2}. He also stated that “the wind speed was highest from 9:00 am to 6:00 pm due to the prevalent southeast (SE) wind and lowest at night and early morning from 12:00 am to 8:00 am due to the dominant westsouthwest (WSW) wind”. From his findings, the average solar flux was 167.49 W m^{−2} averaged over the 4 years. He stated that the solar irradiance of Kalangala was greatest between 11:00 am to 3:00 pm although the area received radiation for 11 h (from 7 am to 6 pm) with an average solar flux of over 300 W m^{−2} solar radiation per day. In this study, Kalangala metrological data for a period of 8 years 2010 to 2018 at a height of 10 m was obtained from [12] and analysed. From the analysis, 2010 and 2018 recorded the highest wind speeds (Fig. 1). The wind speed was highest in the months of July and August at 11.95 m s^{−1} and 10.12 m s^{−1} respectively for the year 2010 and at 11.53 m s^{−1} and 11.24 m s^{−1} for the months of October and July respectively in the year 2018 [12]. The highest wind speed was from 10:00 am in the morning to 5:00 pm in the evening. The wind speed reduced at night and early morning. According to weather Spark [13], the average hourly wind direction in Kalangala district varies throughout the year and is from the south for 7.2 months January 28 to September 3, with a peak percentage of 79% on July 3. Figure 1 shows the average annual Kalangala district wind speed of 8 years.
From Fig. 1, the highest mean speed was in the year 2018 at 5.27 m s^{−1}. This was, therefore, used as the wind design parameter for this study. Figures 2 and 3 show Uganda’s global horizontal Irradiation and Kalangala district annual average solar irradiation for 8 years from 2010 to 2018 respectively. It is noted that the highest mean annual solar irradiation from 2010 to 2018 was 10.03 kWh recorded in the year 2013. Therefore, 10.03 kWh became the design parameter for the solar system of this study.
Wind turbines
Like with windmills, wind turbines take the merit of the wind energy and convert it into another form of energy. In this case study, the wind turbine converts kinetic energy in the wind into electrical energy. Small wind turbines like the one designed for this study are usually selected for local usage [14]. Since the electric energy required for the study was less than 100 kW capacity, this became a system constraint, and therefore, the system is categorized as a microgrid [15]. Microgrid wind turbines are usually installed in the isolated, offgrid and remote areas where there is no power connected to the national grid as the case for Kalangala district [16]. Johari et al. [14] stated that these days, wind turbine technology is used to power vertical axis wind turbines (VAWT) and horizontal axial wind turbine (HAWT), to light up rural villages, as well as irrigation of crops.
The VAWT was selected for this study, because of the following merits; The VAWT is an omnidirectional and, therefore, can receive wind from all directions, unlike HAWT that is required to face in the direction of wind stream all the time in order to give the required optimum output. Since Kalanga district winds are from all directions, VAWT was considered to be the best option. The VAWT is the best choice to be installed in a more turbulent and slow wind speed environment. It can generally start to produce power at very low wind speeds, unlike the HAWT. “The system for VAWT such as gearbox and other equipment can be packed together and installed closer to the ground, hence eliminating the need for extra cost for maintenance and making it easier to be controlled” [14]. The VAWT is quieter during operation as compared to HAWT. However, VAWT is inefficient in highspeed wind environment due to its low starting torques and issues on its dynamic stability [14].
Designing crop drip irrigation system
The two main crops grown in Kalangala district are bananas and palm oil. Banana was selected for this study.
Assumptions made

a.
Size of land: one acre (4046 m^{2}) of banana plantation to be irrigated

b.
Crop to be irrigated: banana

c.
Dripper spacing: 1.524 m

d.
Land slope: 0% land slope

e.
The depth of water source: 8 m

f.
Water source: well, at the corner of the banana field to be irrigated
Crop water requirement
In determining the water required for irrigation, the first step was to determine the amount of water that will be needed for the selected crop. Since the need varies during the season, the highest amount that is expected to be used is selected [17]. Crop water requirement varies with crop spacing. Table 1 shows peak water requirements and spacing for commonly grown crops in Africa.
Spacing of banana plants varies with the type of bananas to be planted. “Bogoya” a local variety of banana is widely spaced whereas short ones such as “Nakytengu” banana variety which was considered for this study is closely spaced. For Nakytengu variety, a spacing of 3 m × 3 m in between the holes gives a banana plant population of 450 per acre and 750 to 900 banana plants per hectare, with a daily water requirement of 25 L d^{−1} [20]. This was the water per meter length of row required, and therefore, the total water required per day for 1 acre of Nakytengu banana plantation was obtained from Eq. 1 [18].
where T_{H20} is total water required per day, T_{LR} the total length of rows and R_{H2O} is water requirement (L m^{−1} d^{−1}). Given that 1 acre is 4046.7 m^{2} and considering this area as square that is to say 63.6 m by 63.6 m, then the total length of rows was obtained through dividing the total area of banana plantation by length of rows [18].
Water required for the whole field per day was then obtained from Eq. 1.
Selection of an inline drip lateral and irrigation time calculation
Assumptions made

An inline drip lateral of 16 mm (pipe size) × 2 L h^{−1} (LPH) × 0.40 m (dripper spacing) was selected for the study.

The irrigation rate for 2 LPH at 0.4 m lateral is 5 LPH.
The peak water requirement is 25 L d^{−1}.
Therefore, the irrigation time (h) was determined from Eq. 2 [18].
Therefore, the proposed irrigation system should be operated for 5 h per section of the field so as to fulfil all water requirements. Since the estimated average availability of the hybrid electricity system is 10 h d^{−1}, then the maximum field section required to be irrigated were obtained from Eq. 3 [18].
Determining the lateral total length (L _{L})
Total Length (L_{L}) required by laterals as shown in Eq. 4 is obtained from dividing the total area (m^{2}) to be irrigated by minimum row spacing length in meters [21].
Total discharge required (T _{ds})
The total lateral discharge is obtained from Eq. 5 by dividing the product of lateral total length and Emitter flow rate (GPH) of the selected lateral by emitter spacing in meters [21].
From Table 2, it can be seen that the maximum inline lateral running length for 16 mm × 2 LPH × 0.4 m is 82 m, and the lateral head loss is 2 m.
Design of submains
The flow rate of submain can be determined by using the total discharge and the required number of sections to be irrigated as given by Eq. 6. When the field is in trapezoidal, triangular and not rectangular in shape, the design can be made by adjusting the total discharge so the design chart made for rectangular fields can be used directly. Since the submain length is normally short, the submain size is designed for a single size and submain slope is assumed to be uniform and downslope [22].
Referring to Table 3, with the discharge of 0.94 LPS (litres per second), the suitable size of submain is 40 mm, 6 Ksc. Total head loss in submain is 2 m. The total length of submain required is 63.6 m. Two (2) submains of 31.8 m each are placed at the centre of the field, and laterals are laid along both sides of the submain for 31.8 m length.
Design of mainline
For the design of the mainline, we refer to Table 4, the PVC mainline data. Here, one submain will be operated at a time; therefore, discharge through the mainline is the same as the discharge through the submain, this is to say 0.94 LPS. Referring to Table 4, we see that 50 mm × 6 Ksc is suitable to carry the flow of 0.94 LPS.
From Table 4, it is observed that the head loss at maximum discharge, that is, at 1.8 LPS through a 50 mm × 6 Ksc PVC pipe is 30 m, but a lesser discharge in this case (0.94 LPS). Therefore, for calculating actual head loss, reference is made to Table 5. It is found that for a 50mm pipe and for a 0.94LPS flow, the head loss is 9.0 m for 1000 m length pipe, but the total length of main line is 100 m. Hence, head loss through a 50mm pipe of 100 m length at 0.94 LPS is
The proposed model design layout for the 1acre banana plantation field was designed as shown in Fig. 4. It consists of two rectangular sections of 31.8 m by 63.6 m each, mainline of 50 mm by 6 Ksc, submains of 40 mm by 6 Ksc, sand filter and a flush point valve.
Design of pump/pump discharge
The required pump discharge is 1.54 LPS. Assuming an operating pressure of 1 kg cm^{−2} ≈ 10 m and lateral head loss of 2 m and in submains of 2 m as indicated in Table 6 and considering head loss from dripper to pump foot value, i.e. water source:
 a.
Operating pressure = 10 m
 b.
Head loss in laterals = 2 m
 c.
Head loss in submains = 2 m
 d.
Head loss in mainline = 0.9 m
 e.
Head loss in fittings (approx.) = 3 m
 f.
Head loss in sand filter = 5 m
 g.
Head loss in disc filter = 3 m
 h.
Head loss in NRV (nonreturn valve) = 1 m
 i.
Static suction and delivery = 8 m
 j.
Static head of the field = 0 m
 k.
Pump suction and delivery = 8 m
Then, the total head will be equivalent to the sum of all heads listed above.
Therefore, Eq. 7 was used to calculate the required pump horsepower (P_{P}) with a discharge of 0.94 LPS at 34.9 m head.
Designing and sizing of the proposed solarwind hybrid as per irrigation demand
In this study, the major aim was to meet a daily irrigation pumping demand for the banana plantation. From Table 7, to irrigate the required two sections of banana plantation, 33,730 L of water will be required, where each section will be irrigated for 5 h. Windsolar electric energy generation by wind turbines and solar PV panels change between months depending on the available weather conditions that include solar irradiation, temperature, air density, wind speed, and air pressure. When the metrological data of Kalangala district (wind speed and solar periods) are put into consideration, it is assumed that more benefit will be gained from solar energy than from wind energy. There are more advantages in using hybrid wind and PV solar technologies as compared to using them separately [23]. Figure 5 is the proposed system connectivity with two inverters, battery, controller, solar panels, wind turbine and charger controller.
The following steps/procedures were adopted from [24] to design the proposed Kalangala irrigation solarwind hybrid system
 a.
Sizing and selection of solar panels
 b.
Sizing and selection of wind turbine
 c.
Sizing and selection of inverter power
 d.
Sizing and selection of charge controller
 e.
Sizing and selection of battery
Sizing and selection of solar panel
When the 544 W (0.73 hp) water pump runs for 10 h d^{−1} pumping water for irrigating bananas, the daily electric energy requirement to be met with solar panels is obtained from Eq. 8 which multiplies the power of the pump and the period of daily use.
By considering charge controller output at the wind turbine, and solar system as 95% (ACDC) and 90% for (DCAC) respectively, then the required power taking into account power efficiencies was calculated using Eq. 9 [23].
Oğuz [23] stated that if it is assumed that there might be general losses that might occur in the system considering the worst situations (cable losses, attachments, development current), then the total power needed per day can be obtained from Eq. 10 accounting for all lo8sses assumed to exist in the system.
The daily energy requirement (ampere h^{−1}) for pumping irrigation water to the field was then determined from Eq. 11, where P_{AH} is daily energy required (ampere h^{−1}) and V_{system} is the battery voltage
From the research conducted by Okou [11], Kalangala’s average wind speed was 5.88 m s^{−1} and the average monthly horizontal was 146.67 kWh m^{−2}, and the average solar irradiance of 4.89 kWh m^{−2} d^{−1} was recorded. The island receives an average of 11 sunshine h d^{−1} [11]. Therefore, Eq. 12 was then used to obtain the necessary PV panel current value, where I_{pv} is the required panel current.
From the calculations above, the selected suitable panel make for the study was Zedfabric™, and the technical specifications for the selected panels is given in Table 8.
Determining the solar panels required for the hybrid
The solar panels required for the hybrid system was obtained from Eq. 13 [23].
Sizing and selection of wind turbine
When the previously sized 0.73 hp (544 W) pump is used to pump water for 10 h d^{−1}, the electric energy requirement to be met with the energy from the wind was calculated from Eq. 14.
where P_{wt} is the energy required in the wind and P_{pump} is the power of the pump (watts)
Average energy requirement (P _{load})
The average energy requirement for the wind turbine was given by Eq. 15
Wind turbine design
Daily energy requirement
According to Oğuz [23], the daily energy required of a wind turbine in amperes per hour can be obtained using Eq. 16.
Determining wind turbine blade radius
From Eq. 17, the blade radius of the turbine capable of generating the desired power was calculated [23].
where (AR) = h/R is the turbine’s aspect ratio which is the ratio between blade height and rotor radius. For this study, a Darrieus VAWT was selected with an aspect ratio of 2 (Fig. 6) since its rotor can take wind from any direction and needs low wind speeds to start [25].
Output coefficient (C_{P}) of a twoblade highspeed turbine varies between 0.4 and 0.5, and the C_{P} for a lowspeed wind turbine with more than 2 blades ranges from 0.2 to 0.45 [23].
Calculating design parameters for the wind turbine
The annual average Kalangala district wind speed for 8 years at 10 m is 5.27 m s^{−1}, and transferring this value from 10 m height to 30 m is given by Hellman equation (18) [26].
where V = speed to the height h, V_{o} is speed to the height h_{o} (frequently referred to as 10 m height) and ∝ is the friction coefficient or Hellman exponent. “This coefficient is frequently assumed as a value of 1/7 for open land and is a function of the topography at a specific site,” [27]. Table 9 is the friction coefficient of various landscapes.
The calculated energy requirement (P_{Load}) for irrigating the banana plantation is 6999 Wh d^{−1}, the annual energy requirement was then obtained;
The size of the wind turbine that is required to be installed to meet the energy demand or requirement was determined based on the following assumptions.
 1.
Coefficient of performance = 0.4
 2.
Density of air = 1.225 kg m^{−3}
 3.
Capacity factor (C_{p}) of 0.30 (that is to say 30% of the time wind machine is producing energy at rated power)
 4.
The transmission losses of rotor to generator = 0.9
 5.
Generator losses of 0.9
 6.
Number of operational hours per year 8760 h
Power density of the wind (power/unit area)
The power density (PD) of moving air is given by Eq. 19 [28].
where WPD is the wind power density, ρ is the air density and V is the wind speed. Air density is determined according to varying sea level degrees of accuracy.
Actual wind power density to be converted to useful energy
According to [23], the actual power density as shown in Eq. 20 is a product of wind power density, capacity factor, transmission and generator losses.
Annual useful energy density
The annual useful wind energy density was obtained as a product of wind power density and total operational hours per year as shown in Eq. 21.
The rotor size and turbine rating estimation
A wind turbine rotor is the organ that transforms the kinetic energy of wind to mechanical energy. For this reason, it is very important for wind turbines. As shown in Eq.. 22, the rotor size was determined from the swept area of the turbine.
But the swept area for the Darrieus or Savonious wind turbine can also be obtained from Eq. 23
Using an aspect ratio of 2 (for turbines with more than two blades), that is, \( (AR)=\frac{h}{R}\ \mathrm{therefore}, \) \( \frac{h}{R}=2 \), then h = 2R.
From Eq. 23, we obtained the swept area.
The height of the blades was then obtained from the aspect ratio as given in Eq. 24.
Power rating of the turbine
The output of a wind turbine depends on the turbine’s size and the wind’s speed through the rotor [29]. The turbine rated power as shown in Eq. 25 was obtained
Actual rated power of the turbine rating
“The capacity factor is defined as the actual power output over a certain period of time as a proportion of a wind turbine/facility’s maximum capacity” [30]. Equation 26 was then used to estimate the actual rated power and a capacity factor C_{P} of 0.30 was selected for the study (that is to say, 30% of time wind machine produces energy at the rated power).
Thus, a 1kW rated power wind turbine would provide desired annual energy under the given situation
Speed of the turbine
According to Ragheb [31], for gridconnected wind turbines with three rotor blades, optimal wind tip speed ratio has to be reported as 7, with values over the range 6–8. Therefore, Eq. 27 was then used to determine the required speed of the turbine.
where TSR is the tip speed ratio (7)
Assumptions made
The above power rating is based on the assumption that the average Kalangala district wind speed of 6.0 m s^{−1} at 30 m height will be available through the year, 8760 h, which is not the case, and that is why we have taken the capacity factor into account.
Technical specification of the required wind turbine (1 kW)
As per the calculations above, a wind turbine was selected with similar specifications and Table 10 is the specifications for the proposed turbine.
Hybrid solarwind system operational experimental description
This hybrid solarwind system considered as a case study is a combination of wind and photovoltaic subsystems as shown in Fig. 5 above. Basing on the design calculations, a 1kW wind subsystem was selected for this system, and its generator was equipped with a direct driven permanentmagnet synchronous generator, diode rectifier and (DC/DC) converter for the tracking of maximum power point [19, 20]. There are 12 photovoltaic panels of 5.23 A. The variable DC output voltage from the panels is controlled by another (DC/DC) buck used for the MPPT through regulating the output current IPV. The common DC bus collects the total energy from the photovoltaic subsystems and wind and uses it partly to charge the battery bank and partly to supply the weak grid to the water pump (AC load) via a singlephase inverter. Figures 7 and 8 show respectively the block diagrams of proposed maximum power point tracking control for PV subsystems and the wind [32].
Sizing and selection of inverter for the proposed hybrid
For this study, one inverter was proposed to be used for both wind turbine and solar panels, making the system more convenient and on reducing the complexity of the system. Considering inverter output of 90%, the required inverter value was given by Eq. 28.
where P_{inverter} is the inverter power in watts
It was assumed that the irrigation pump would draw excess current for a short time and that 700 W full sine inverter should be selected of which is not far from the calculated value of 604.4 W. The technical specifications for the proposed inverter are given in Table 11.
Sizing and selecting the system battery
Accumulators are assumed to be used in the system to store DC voltage from solar panels and wind turbine. The objective is to store surplus electric energy generated from the panels and turbine into accumulators.
where P_{load} in this case is power loads from Eq. 10 and Eq. 15 respectively and V_{Battery} the battery voltage
For this study, a 200Ah battery was selected to be used for the system, and the number of batteries required was obtained from Eq. 30.
Finite element analysis of the turbine
The wind turbine was designed using SolidWorks 2019 software as shown in Fig. 9, with a blade height of 2.82 m and a radius of 1.41 m. The model was then simulated in SolidWorks 2019 flow simulation environment, and therefore, the turbine flow behaviour, static pressure, turbulence intensity and stress distribution was analysed at three times the peak wind speed of Kalangala district at an elevation of 30 m (that is to say at 20 m s^{−1}), and the results are shown in Figs. 10 and 11.
Cost analysis
Since the windsolar hybrid system is a longterm efficient alternative in pumping water for irrigation in comparison to other types of energy, it is important that the cost remains as low as possible. Table 12 shows the total investment of the Kalangala proposed solarwind hybrid irrigation system.
Investment
The design lifetime of a typical wind turbine (VAWT/HAWT) is 20 years, with low turbulence of lake offshore wind conditions causing very low vibrations and fatigue stresses [33].
Total project cost = 73,812,000 UGX
Payments
The payments, including the initial payments/cash flows, were used to calculate the net present value and the real rate of return over a 5year project time since this is the main economic aspect of the analysis. For simplicity, tax payments, credits and depreciation credits were not considered [33].
Assuming that the capital cost for the project is obtained as a loan, then the interest payment on the loan was put into consideration.
Operation and maintenance
According to Blanco [33], the maintenance and operational cost of a wind turbine is 15% of the total project cost without the labour cost
Total expenditure
= Total project cost + operation & maintenance cost over expected lifetime
Current income and expenditures per year
The proposed area for banana plantation is 1 acre (4046.86 m^{2}), and the proposed banana variety is Nakytengu with a spacing is 10 ft. × 10 ft. (9 m^{2}). Therefore, the number of banana plants to be planted is 450.
Assumption
Price of a mature banana bunch is 9000 UGX.
Banana plant is a perennial crop which takes 9 months on average to grow and produce a bunch of bananas [34].
Gross yearly income
Gross yearly income from sell of banana bunches assuming all plants have put on fruits is:
Net income stream per year
Table 13 was then constructed over the 5 years for the solarwind hybrid for banana field irrigation.
Net present value of income stream at r = 5% per year real rate of interest is 12,935,468 UGX.
Results and discussions
Proposed hybrid system
Water required for irrigating 450 banana plants per day is 34 m^{3} d^{−1}. The required irrigation time is 5 h d^{−1}. Maximum field sections required for irrigation 1 acre are two sections, the required pump horsepower is 544 W, and the number of solar panels at rating of 5.23 A required are 12 pieces. The design turbine speed is 201 r.p.m., and the rating of the wind turbine required for the system is 1 kW. The inverter size is 700 W, and the number of batteries required by the system is seven pieces at rating of 200 Ah. From optimization results, the total project cost is 73.8 m UGX and the net income stream of 2.99 m UGX per year with yearly net real rate of return of 3.5% per year. The major demerits of independent renewable energy sources are unavailability at all times when needed and high capital cost and energy unavailability of rated wind speed requirement. Thus, a hybrid energy system (solarwind) helps in overcoming the drawbacks of renewable energy sources and thus provides a continuous supply of electricity.
Conclusion
Solarwind hybrid energy system is the most feasible economic solutions in lowering electricity bills; it also avoids the high costs encountered during extending grid power lines to remote areas and provides a clean renewable nonpolluting source of electricity. In this paper, the water requirement for irrigating one acre of Nakytengu banana plantation in Kalanga district was determined, pipeline for the irrigation system and design layout made, power to meet the irrigation demand determined and a solarwind hybrid system sized for supplying the required electric power for irrigation. The system was simulated for flow behaviour, static pressure, turbulence intensity and stress at a speed, three times the average wind speed of Kalangala district elevated at 30 m above sea level, and the results showed that the system could still work properly without undergoing through deformation. Project cost analysis was made, and the results showed the project’s yearly net real rate of return of 3.5% per year, indicating that the project is feasible. Thus, the analysis performed in this paper will set guidelines for energy consultants or engineers and for those who want to set up a solarwind irrigation system for drip irrigation.
Availability of data and materials
Not applicable
Abbreviations
 AC:

Alternating current
 AR:

Aspect ratio
 DC:

Direct current
 HAWT:

Horizontal axis wind turbine
 L.P.H:

Litres per hour
 LPS:

Litres per second
 MPPT:

Maximum power point tracking
 NACRRI:

National Crops Resources Research Institute
 NPHC:

National Population and Housing Census
 NRV:

Nonreturn valve
 PD:

Power density
 PV:

Photovoltaic
 PVC:

Polyvinyl chloride
 UBOS:

Uganda Bureau of Statistics
 VAWT:

Vertical axis wind turbine
 WPD:

Wind power density
References
UBOS, “Uganda Bureau of Statistics 2017 Statistical Abstract.” [Online]. Available: https://www.ubos.org/wpcontent/uploads/publications/03_20182017_Statistical_Abstract.pdf. [Accessed: 04 Nov 2019]
Shivrath Y, Narayana PB, Thirumalasetty S, Narsaiah EL (2012) Design & integration of windsolar hybrid energy system for drip irrigation pumping application. Int J Mod Eng Res 2(4):2947–2950
Khan Z, Linares P, Garcíagonzález J (2017) Integrating water and energy models for policy driven applications. A review of contemporary work and recommendations for future developments. Renew Sust Energ Rev 67:1123–1138
Ronad BF, Jangamshetti SH (2015) Optimal cost analysis of windsolar hybrid system powered AC and DC irrigation pumps using HOMER. 4th Int Conf Renew Energy Res Appl 5:1038–1042
Turyareeba PJ (2001) Renewable energy: its contribution to improved standards of living and modernisation of agriculture in Uganda. Renew Energy 24:453–457
Odum HT (1971) Environment, power and society. WileyInterscience, New York
Bekele G, Tadesse G (2012) Feasibility study of small Hydro/PV/Wind hybrid system for offgrid rural electrification in Ethiopia. Appl Energy 97:5–15
Fahmy FH, Ahmed NM, Farghally HM (2012) Optimization of renewable energy power system for small scale brackish reverse osmosis desalination unit and a tourism motel in Egypt. Smart Grid Renew Energy 3:43–50
NPHC, “Main report national population and housing census,” 2014. [Online]. Available: www.ubos.org. Accessed 4 Nov 2019
Chandra D, Singh PK A, Alam T, Bishnoi R, Singh AK 2014. Developing hybrid wind and solar powered irrigation system. Environ. Sustain. Concepts Princ Evidences Innov. pp. 99–105
Okou R, Niwagaba E, Kyahingwa O, Edimu M, Sebitosi AB 2013. Considerations for renewable energy minigrid systems for isolated areas in Uganda. SIDA regional collaboration conference, Bagamoyo, Tanzania
NASA, “POWER Data Access Viewer,” 2019. [Online]. Available: https://power.larc.nasa.gov/dataaccessviewer/. [Accessed: 10 Jul 2019]
W. Spark, “Average weather in Kalangala, Uganda, year round  Weather Spark,” 2018. [Online]. Available: https://weatherspark.com/y/97220/AverageWeatherinKalangalaUgandaYearRound. [Accessed: 01 Jun 2018].
Johari M, Jalil M, Shariff MM (2018) Comparison of horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT) and vertical axis wind turbine (VAWT). Int J Eng Technol 7(4.13):74–80
Lasseter RH (2002) “Microgrids,” in 2002 IEEE Power Engineering Society Winter Meeting. Conference Proceedings (Cat No 02CH37309) 1:305–308
Eid AM, AbdelSalam M, AbdelRahman MT (2006) Verticalaxis wind turbine modeling and performance with axialflux permanent magnet synchronous generator for battery charging applications. In: 2006 Eleventh International Middle East Power Systems Conference, vol 1, pp 162–166
Sinton CW, Butler R, Winnett R (2004) Guide to solarpowered water pumping systems in New York State. NYSERDA
Mahindra, “Design of EPC Drip Irrigation System  Mahindra EPC.” [Online]. Available: http://www.epcmahindra.com/pdf/how_to_arrive.pdf. Accessed 19 July 2018.
Brower C, Heibloem M 1986. Irrigation water management: Irrigation water needs. FAO Training Manual 3. Rome, Italy
NAADS, “Banana production guide – National Agricultural Advisory Services,” 2019. [Online]. Available: http://www.naads.or.ug/publication/bananaproductionguide/. [Accessed: 06 Jun 2019]
Hunter, “Drip irrigation design and installation guide.” [Online]. Available: https://www.hunterindustries.com/sites/default/files/dg_plddesignguide_dom.pdf. [Accessed: 06 Jun 2019]
Wu IP, Gitlin HM (1977) Design of drip irrigation submain. J Irrig Drain Div 103(2):231–243
Oğuz Y, Özsoy MF (2015) Sizing, design, and installation of an isolated windphotovoltaic hybrid power system with battery storage for laboratory general illumination in Afyonkarahisar, Turkey. J Energy South Africa 26(4):70–80
Adejumobi IA, Akinboro FG, Olajide MB (2011) Hybrid solar and wind power: an essential for information communication technology infrastructure and people in rural communities. IJRRAS 9(1):130–138
Brusca S, Lanzafame R, Messina M (2014) Design of a verticalaxis wind turbine: how the aspect ratio affects the turbine’s performance. Int J Energy Environ Eng 5(4):333–340
BañuelosRuedas F, AngelesCamacho C, RiosMarcuello S (2011) Methodologies used in the extrapolation of wind speed data at different heights and its impact in the wind energy resource assessment in a region. In: Wind farmtechnical regulations, potential estimation and siting assessment, InTech
Ochieng PO, Manyonge AW, Oduor AO (2013) Mathematical modelling of power output in a wind energy conversion system. Int J Eng Sci Math 2(4):19
Hughes T (2000) “Lesson number 1. In an Oklahoma wind power tutorial series,” Univ. Oklahoma
EWEA, “The European Wind Energy Association  EWEA,” 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.ewea.org/. [Accessed: 21 Jul 2018]
Wind Watch, “National Wind Watch  Output From Industrial Wind Power,” National Wind Watch, Inc. [Online]. Available: https://www.windwatch.org/faqoutput.php. [Accessed: 21 Jul 2018]
Ragheb M (2009) “Optimal rotor tip speed ratio,” Available from NetFiles Univ. Illinois UrbanaChampaign, Last Modif
Dali M, Belhadj J, Roboam X (2006) Conception et commande de systèmes hybrides photovoltaiqueéolien. Rev Int génie électrique 9(6):719–752
Blanco MI (2009) The economics of wind energy. Renew Sust Energ Rev 13(6–7):1372–1382
Simmonds NW (1953) The development of the banana fruit. J Exp Bot 4(1):87–105
Acknowledgements
Not applicable
Funding
The fund for data collection was obtained from the Makerere University Department of Agricultural and Bioengineering
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
SS devised the main conceptual ideas; collected, processed, and analysed the data; and wrote major parts of the paper. NK contributed to the methodological design, supervised and critiqued data collection and analysis, revised the manuscript, and made the suggestions for improvements. NB contributed to the case study description, revised the manuscript, and made the suggestions for improvement. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable
Consent for publication
All the authors agreed to publish the article.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Ssenyimba, S., Kiggundu, N. & Banadda, N. Designing a solar and wind hybrid system for smallscale irrigation: a case study for Kalangala district in Uganda. Energ Sustain Soc 10, 6 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s1370502002401
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s1370502002401